Affordability’s Record Streak Is Ending, and Investors Should Already Be Repricing Risk
National Bank’s latest housing affordability index just delivered a number that should catch every serious investor’s attention: eleven consecutive quarters of improvement, the longest streak ever recorded. That sounds like good news. For anyone underwriting a deal on current assumptions, it is actually a warning that the tailwind is running out of road.
The mechanics matter here. Mortgage payments on a typical home fell to 50.9% of median pre-tax household income in Q3, down 0.7 points. But that improvement was not driven by cheaper financing. It came from a 1.0% drop in seasonally adjusted home prices and a 0.7% rise in household income, which together absorbed a 0.2-point drag from rising rates. In other words, the asset got cheaper and borrowers got marginally richer, even as the cost of debt was already climbing. That is not the kind of affordability gain a landlord or a flipper should build a thesis around.
National Bank economist Kyle Dahms frames the bigger picture bluntly: the cumulative improvement since the 2023 peak now approaches 15 percentage points, yet the Composite 10 index still sits 9.7 points above its historical average and 8.5 points above pre-pandemic levels. For investors, that is the real signal. This is not a market returning to normal. It is a market easing off an extreme while remaining structurally expensive relative to income, which keeps a floor under rental demand even as ownership stays out of reach for many buyers.

Now look at the rate side, where the risk is concentrating. The bank’s 5-year fixed benchmark mortgage rate jumped 38 basis points in October, its sharpest monthly rise in four years, pushing it to the highest level since mid-2024. National Bank’s own modeling shows that if prices hold flat through October, rising rates alone would add 2.4 points to the payment burden, pushing the index back up toward 53.1%, even after accounting for income gains. That is a meaningful deterioration packed into a single quarter, and it lands at a moment when the Bank of Canada does not expect inflation to return to target until 2028.
Housing affordability is facing in Q4 its most significant interest-rate challenge since 2022.
For investors, the strategic read is not “affordability is improving, buy now” or “rates are rising, retreat.” It is more precise than that. Higher carrying costs reduce buyer leverage and liquidity, which historically pressures prices lower, a pattern the Bank of Canada has already documented when it found that lower rates in the past simply got absorbed into higher prices rather than improving affordability. That cuts both ways now: tighter credit conditions could compress valuations further in the near term, which matters for anyone timing an acquisition, while sustained unaffordability on the ownership side continues to support rental demand and pricing power for income properties.
The takeaway for KG Invest readers is simple discipline. Do not extrapolate eleven quarters of improvement into a forecast. Underwrite new acquisitions against a rate environment that is already deteriorating, stress test cash flow at today’s 5-year fixed levels rather than Q3’s average, and watch the spread between ownership costs and rental yields closely through Q4. The data suggests the easy phase of this recovery is behind us.
Source: Better Dwelling, “Canadian Housing Affordability’s Record Recovery May End Soon: NBF”


